Solutions

Oficina de Defensoría de los Derechos de la Infancia (ODI)

ODI in Mexico exposed how school authorities failed to protect children from childhood sexual violence. This included staff colluding in the abuse of very young children and coordinated cover-ups. In 2021, their work shaped a landmark court case, and contributed to reforms, including school redesign and improved investigative practices.

Oficina de Defensoría de los Derechos de la Infancia A.C.
1

Key themes

Practitioners working in school settings (e.g., teachers and social workers) are often able to detect patterns that formal oversight mechanisms fail to recognise. This could include unclear reporting channels or cultural norms that discourage disclosure. Practice-based knowledge can also reveal structural problems in how schools respond to allegations and safeguard children.

What these case studies show 

These case studies illustrate how practice-based knowledge (PbK) is used in real world settings to improve childhood sexual violence prevention and response. Each case focuses on what practitioners or survivor-led groups learned through action, reflection, and decision-making in their own contexts, and how that knowledge was taken forward. 

What these case studies do and do not do 

The case studies do not aim to produce generalisable findings. Instead, they offer context-specific insight into how practice unfolds, where challenges emerge, and how actors respond in real time. The absence of evaluation or impact data should not be interpreted as evidence for or against effectiveness. 

How to use these insights in your own work 

These case studies are intended to support reflection rather than replication. Readers may find them useful for: 

  • identifying questions to explore within their own practice
  • recognising patterns or tensions that resonate with their own settings
  • anticipating practical, ethical, or institutional challenges before they arise 

Ethical use and limitations 

Documenting and sharing PbK requires careful attention to safety, consent, power, and potential harm, particularly when engaging with sensitive experiences of child sexual violence. The ethical principles guiding this work are set out in the PbK Guidance Framework 

Scope and limits of the knowledge shared 

Each case study reflects the type and depth of knowledge available within its context. Differences in format, detail, and focus reflect variation in purpose, access, and the conditions under which knowledge was documented and shared.  

Content warning  

Some of the case studies include details of childhood sexual violence. Each case study includes specific content notes to support informed engagement. Please take care of your well-being as you read and step away if needed. For additional support, you may find it helpful to consult the following resources:  

2

Context

ODI

Oficina de Defensoría de los Derechos de la Infancia (Office of Advocacy of the Rights of Children (ODI) is a frontline organisation in Mexico that advocates for children’s rights and represents child survivors of sexual violence in courts. A significant part of ODI’s work has focused on cases in schools, where, despite formal oversight, incidents involving multiple perpetrators acting together have repeatedly come to light across several states. 

Through years of direct legal representation of child survivors of sexual violence, ODI built a robust body of practice-based knowledge based on case files, courtroom experience, children’s testimonies, and reports from families. By closely examining 45 cases across 12 states between 2017 and 2024, ODI identified recurring patterns of childhood sexual violence in schools as well as state inaction. 

3

From insight to action

What was learned from practice-based knowledge:

Note: This section contains descriptions of childhood sexual violence.

ODI began identifying patterns and systemic gaps:  

  • Patterns of childhood sexual violence: Groups of school staff (teachers, principals, administrative staff, and maintenance workers) were acting together to subject children as young as 3 to 7 years old to physical, sexual and psychological violence. Victims were often sedated and sometimes forced to attack each other while being filmed. These patterns emerged across states, in both public and private schools.
  • Hidden spaces: Childhood sexual violence was often perpetrated in secluded spaces, such as windowless storage rooms, which were difficult to monitor.
  • Institutional failures: The Public Education Secretariat (SEP) delayed investigations, tried to dissuade families from reporting, and often closed cases without action.
  • Flawed investigative practices: Inadequate techniques for interviewing young children meant many testimonies were disregarded, weakening cases as a result. 

Action:

  • Published reports: In 2021, ODI released It’s a Secret: Child Sexual Exploitation in Schools, documenting 18 cases across seven states with the distinct pattern of multiple perpetrators and very young children. A second report in 2024 expanded the documentation to another 27 cases across 12 states. Both combined ODI’s case files with public records and media reports, making systemic patterns visible.
  • Litigation: ODI used their practice-based knowledge to highlight these issues before the court while representing a group of children in a high-profile legal case against the Public Education Secretariat (SEP).
4

Real world impact

Public attention

"It’s a Secret: Child Sexual Exploitation in Schools" sparked national and international coverage by over 50 media outlets, with the President of Mexico publicly questioned on the state’s response.

Judicial decision

In 2021 ODI represented a group of children in a high-profile legal case against the Public Education Secretariat.

Investigation

The Office of the Attorney General opened a national investigation into all reported cases of childhood sexual violence in schools - a key outcome following the publication of ODI’s report.

*This was a result of the judicial decision, which was a result of the report, "It’s a Secret: Child Sexual Exploitation in Schools".

Redesigning schools

A court order mandated that the Public Education Secretariat eliminate hidden spaces (such as rooms without windows) within schools and ensure that the visibility of what happens inside classrooms is not obstructed.

*This was a result of the judicial decision, which was a result of the report, "It’s a Secret: Child Sexual Exploitation in Schools".

Improved investigative practices

The Attorney General’s Office was required to adopt specialised methods for supporting young victims (both boys and girls) to testify within a reasonable time frame.

*This was a result of the judicial decision, which was a result of the report, "It’s a Secret: Child Sexual Exploitation in Schools".

Curriculum integration

Schools were required to include sexual violence education to help students recognise childhood sexual violence and seek support.

*This was a result of the judicial decision, which was a result of the report, "It’s a Secret: Child Sexual Exploitation in Schools".

State liability

The judge condemned the Mexican State as jointly liable for the reparation of the damage while sentencing a teacher.

*This was a result of the judicial decision, which was a result of the report, "It’s a Secret: Child Sexual Exploitation in Schools".

Why this matters: The value of practice-based knowledge

ODI’s frontline legal work shows how knowledge generated through practice can reveal patterns of harm and institutional failure that might otherwise remain hidden. In this case, insights from direct case handling brought to light organised childhood sexual violence in schools and forced national attention on issues the state had ignored. 

Practice-based knowledge is not a substitute for formal evidence; the two are most powerful when used together. While research provides depth, validation, and generalisable findings, practice-based insights can highlight urgent gaps, shape the questions that research and investigations must address, and ensure that systemic failures are not overlooked. Together, they strengthen the broader knowledge base. 

5

If you're working in a similar context

ODI’s experience shows that insights from practice can be a powerful starting point to uncover systemic gaps in safeguarding. Whether you work in schools, other child care institutions, or in legal and advocacy roles, consider reflecting on the following questions: 

For practitioners and school/child-care professionals 

  • In your setting, are there physical or structural features (hidden spaces, unsupervised areas, weak reporting systems) that may increase risks for children?
  • Do you see recurring obstacles such as families being discouraged from reporting, or children’s complaints being dismissed?
  • Are there child-friendly reporting and referral channels that children and families trust? What is missing? 

For lawyers, advocates, and policy actors 

  • Do you see patterns across cases that indicate systemic failings (e.g., cover-ups, delayed investigations, negligence by authorities)?
  • Where does practice-based knowledge from your cases point to the need for policy reform, new investigative procedures, or accountability mechanisms? 

Overall reflective questions 

  • How can you gather these patterns from practice to show that the problem is systemic, not isolated?
  • Where does your practice-based knowledge from day-to-day experiences point to the need for deeper research or evidence-building?
  • How can you keep these failures visible when institutions are slow to act? 
6

Sources and contact

[1] Ansolabehere, K., Azuela, M., Cacho, L., Dresser, D., Gil Antón, M., Guevara, J., Meyer, L., Pérez, J. M., Vázquez, L. D., La Oficina de Defensoría de los Derechos de la Infancia A.C., Griesbach Guizar, M. (Coord.), Mora Lopez, D. (Invest.), Gil Bartomeu, M., Pliego Pérez, Y., Soriano Rodríguez, G., & Espinal Enriquez, J. (2021). “It’s a secret”: Child exploitation in schools. Oficina de Defensoría de los Derechos de la Infancia A.C. 

[2] Harris, L. (2024, August 21). “Child testimony is absolutely pivotal”: Margarita Griesbach of Oficina de Defensoría de los Derechos de la Infancia on litigation strategies, communication campaigns, and the importance of child-centered justice systems. Solutions for Ending Childhood Sexual Violence. https://solutionsforcsv.org/resource/conversation-with-margarita-griesbach/ 

[3] Oficina de Defensoría de los Derechos de la Infancia A.C. (2024, July). “It’s a secret”: Child exploitation in schools. https://dispensariodi.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/Report_IT%C2%B4S-A-SECRET_2024.pdf 

[4] To Zero. (2024, November). A vision to zero: A roadmap to ending childhood sexual violence. https://to-zero.org/our-vision/our-report  

Last updated: 27 February 2026